The Fat Pelican
It's the most famous bar there. I'm not a huge fan, but you have to go to say you've been. It's one of those places. You walk into a giant beer cooler and select from hundreds of beers and then proceed to the register to pay.
This place is a legend. Cool enough to walk into the cooler in the back and check out their selection of beers, pick what you want and go pay the bartender. Hot enough to be the filming location for the Hot Summer remake video starring the OuterBanks stars. Seriously, if you are 21 and up, GO!!!
A bar you would see in a tropical island, with a beer cave on a honor system. Good vibes always.